Great eye pencil
I really love how easily this pencil glides on and the black/grey colour is perfect...dark enough without being too dark. It smudges easily too and then sets. Zero irritation for my sensitive eyes/skin.
Englady
Verified Purchase
Eye pencil in Taupe
I like this eye pencil. I ordered in Taupe and it is a little lighter than I thought it would be. So I am a little bummed. It is more blonde than I thought it would be.
ShannonV
Verified Purchase
jane iredale eye pencil
i have used this twice, it goes on smooth and does not smudge. I like it.
connieb
Verified Purchase
Does not smudge during day.
I've used this product for a few years because of the ingredient quality and staying power. Having green eyes & dark brown hair, I find that 3 shades work for me: Basic Black for evening lighting and Black Grey or Black Brown to enhance my eye color more softly during the day.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Unusable
I love this brand and use several items daily. This pencil worked well out of the box but the sharpener is defective. The pencil breaks off when using the sharpener and makes the pencil unusable. Very disappointing.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Smooth
This Jane Iredale eye pencil goes on easily and smoothly. The black/grey color is perfect, not too dark and not too light. But the best thing is that I can sharpen it to my satisfaction.
Delighted
Verified Purchase
Didn't like the color.
I thought taupe would be good for my gray eyes but found the color was way too light. I won't purchase this again.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
a staple
Just a great classic black pencil eyeliner. Very reliable and does the job for a smokey eye look.
arielledmd
Verified Purchase
Good Everyday Eyeliner
Love Jane Iredale products! The Midnight Blue was lovely and more interesting than basic black. This liner applied smoothly, but did not last long. It looks great if it doesn't smudge under your eyes, but unfortunately, it did smudge on me. It may be a tradeoff to get the clean ingredients.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Nice eye pencil
I purchased this in brown, it’s a nice shade not harsh, goes on smoothly
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Jane iredale eyeliner
My favorite shade is navy blue which is difficult to find. Pencil sharpens beautiful, no waste trying to get it to a point. I always buy 2 to make sure I never run out.
Buffie
Verified Purchase
Just as described
This eye pencil is great. I wanted it for under my eyes. Kind of a soft line effect. It’s a perfect color and does exactly what I’d hoped!!
Margay
Verified Purchase
Great eyeliner
This eyeliner goes on so smooth and does not smudge. For a matte look this eyeliner is my Goto and how easy it is to apply is a huge benefit.
Calivixen
Verified Purchase
Easy to apply
I think Jane Iredale has reformulated their eye pencils, as they are softer and creamier than they used to be. In the past, they would crumble when you tried to use them and I have not had that problem with the last two pencils I purchased. I love them for tightlining and they don't irritate my eyes or shed particles into them.
BethD
Verified Purchase
Taupe Eye Pencil
I've always used a dark brown pencil in past years, but as I am getting a little more silver, I find that this pencil compliments my hazel eyes and light skin tone. It is just enough!
HappyLady
Verified Purchase
Average Eye Pencil
I really like eye pencils to provide inner eye lid color. This one smears too much and isn’t long wearing. I won’t be buying again.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Ugly and too harsh
Terrible liner. Doesn't go on well and draws a terrible line that can't be smudged. Threw it away.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Eyeliner
Great eyeliner goes on easily looks great
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Great Eye Pencil
Jane Iredale's eye pencil - in all colors - goes on smoothly and stays in place beautifully. No tugging or stretching your eyelid needed. The color is rich and the ingredients are formulated in such a way as to smoothly glide on and yet stay in place without a smudge. I love all Jane Iredale products and this is no exception!
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Goes on smooth
Jane Iredale always has good products and you can never go wrong.
JEF
Verified Purchase
Review Summary
Have you purchased this product? Write a Review
