Great product
I really like this pencil. At first, I thought it was a little rough on my eyelid. I was pressing too hard. I got the hang of it. I like the color. Softer for my over 50 eyes. I now prefer it over liquid liner. Wish it came with a sharpener. But that was easy to pick up at the drug store. I'd buy it again.
cathyf
Verified Purchase
Crumbles!
I purchased a blue and a black/brown pencil at the same time. The black/brown one crumbles at each use, so I literally cannot use it.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Good eye pencil
I like this pencil a lot. It lasts all day long and easy to apply.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Favorite of all time
Love this pencil. Perfect consistency... goes on smoothly and easily. Perfect color! Part of my morning routine.
Loey
Verified Purchase
Doesn’t Pull on Eyelid
Love how creamy the eye liner is! It doesn’t pull at all when applying to eyes. Wish it was waterproof because it runs under my eyes after a few hours.
AnnMG
Verified Purchase
LOVE LOVE LOVE this eyeliner!!
I tried my jane iredale eye pencil in white for the first time today and I absolutely love it. It is a magical highlight for brightening eyes!
ChristinaG
Verified Purchase
Perfect eyebrow pencil
Love the Jane Iredale pencil in taupe. Perfect color for my eyebrows, stays put once applied and a great price through LovelySkin.
Bunny
Verified Purchase
jane iredale Eye Pencil
I bought the taupe pencil and I use it as a liner and brow pencil. It goes on very easily and has a great color and texture. Seems like the liner itself is quite soft and does not appear to last that long.
Karovd
Verified Purchase
Best eye pencil
If you are looking for a good eye pencil, you found it. This is exactly what I wanted to find. It leaves a perfect trace and it lasts for the whole day!
Alexandralop
Verified Purchase
Great eyeliner for sensitive eyes!
This is the only eyeliner I have found that does not irritate my eyes. The colors are beautiful. It applies smoothly and lasts all day. Highly recommend!!!
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Stays on
After using liquid and gel liners decided to try this pencil. It lasts all day and goes on pretty easy. Looking to try different colors. Tried the basic brown, it’s noticeable and not super dark.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Eyeliner
This is the best eyeliner that I have used. I have used it for many years. The black/brown is the perfect color for me even with a lot of gray hair. I have tried to find other brands but always come back to this one.
DrMoira
Verified Purchase
Should have trusted the reviws
While it goes on smoothly, I bought a color that is way too light and doesn’t show much. In addition, it disappears after a while, and that is what I had read about it and didn’t pay attention to.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
jane iredale Eye pencil
Excellent! I have several eye pencils over the years. This one works, very easy to apply. Plan to buy more.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Smooth long lasting and natural
Love this eyeliner. It applies smooth and wipes easily if you need a correction before it sets. Once it sets it is long lasting. The fact that Jane Iredale is a natural makeup line only makes it better.
Hlfbreed
Verified Purchase
Jane iredale
This pencil is fast-paced because I have oily skin.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Nice pencil, great color, but doesn't wear long
I'm a Jane Iredale fan, and I do like this pencil after I first apply it. The Taupe shade, especially, is very natural and it applies without much tugging. However, the color doesn't last long and has to be reapplied throughout the day. My eyes tend to be watery in the dry winter weather,so maybe this is my problem. But I've had better luck with BareMinerals pencil liners in terms of lasting wear. The Jane Iredale eye pencils are nice quality, of course, but this is definitely not a long-wearing, smear-proof liner.
Cynders
Verified Purchase
Smooth and non-irritating
Finding a liner that goes in smooth, has intense color, stays on, and doesn't irritate is very difficult for me. But, this one does all that. Will continue using this!
tchris
Verified Purchase
Very smooth application - nice!
I really like this pencil. It goes on smoothly and doesn't smear. Happy with this and use it daily.
ToriC
Verified Purchase
Great eyebrow pencil
I don’t like this as an eyeliner but it works great as a brow pencil in taupe.
Knisholm
Verified Purchase
Review Summary
Have you purchased this product? Write a Review
