Smears in hot weather
I use a very fine liner brush from a high-end company. I noticed that in hot weather, this product runs and smears. Not a good look for anyone! I am happy to say that I've taken it out for another try now that it's winter, and it's doing a lot better. This is a good way to get a natural look for a liner, one that is not too dramatic.
Like the color no staying power
I like the color but it faded quickly on my oily skin. Not nearly as good as Jane Iredale liners. I ended up blending with the Jane Iredale to keep it from fading on my lids. Might be better on non-oily prone skin.