Return to Product Details
Jane Iredale Eyeliner Eye Pencil - Basic Black

Reviews For jane iredale Eye Pencil

$24.00

Filtered by: Star Rating: 5 stars Clear Filters

121 Reviews
September 23, 2025

Eyeliner

Soft, easy to blend!

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

August 29, 2025

perfect color

It goes on smoothly without tugging the skin. The Black/Grey color adds a perfect amount of depth without being too harsh. It stays put all day and does not give me raccoon eyes.

Profile Photo

HJ

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 23, 2025

perfect

loved it! Perfect color and stays put, no smearing

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

from California

Age Group: 70-79

Straight Hair

Normal Skin

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

July 18, 2025

a great basic

I love almost everything by Jane Iredale that I have purchased, and this eye pencil is no exception! Creamy, yet long lasting - and the dark greyblack color looks very good on with dark brown brows and eyes - a little less severe than straight black, and yet with a bit more impact than brown pencil.

Profile Photo

Redwoodgirl

from California

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

June 25, 2025

What I was looking for!

I had been looking for a replacement of a creamy eye pencil since the one I had been using had been discontinued. Most companies had either gone to a gel based liner or the pencils were too dry. This one by Jane Iredale isperfect! Cream, goes on smoothly, lasts until I easily was it off at the end of day. I had purchased the basic brown shade, but will be making other selections!

Profile Photo

Lisa410

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

May 23, 2025

Nice color

Colors as showson the page and it's easy to apply.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

September 10, 2024

Smooth Application and Long-Lasting Color!

The jane iredale Eye Pencil has become my go-to for everyday makeup. The formula is so creamy and smooth, it glides on effortlessly without tugging or pulling. The color is rich and pigmented, and it stays put all day without smudging or fading, even in humid weather. I also love that it’s made with natural ingredients that don’t irritate my eyes. It’s perfect for creating both a subtle daytime look or a more defined, bold line for the evening. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a high-quality, long-lasting eyeliner!

Profile Photo

Scoobydoo

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

September 08, 2024

5 stars for jane iredale eye Pencil

I love the jane iredale Eye Pencil. The color goes on so smoothly and does not irritate my eyes! The color remains all day around my eyes and doesn't smear during the day at all. I'm so very happy I bought this eye liner from LovelySkin and will continue to buy this product from now on. I love ordering from LovelySkin for so many products. They are so efficient with sending out your order very quickly- within 3 days after placing your order you've received it already!

Profile Photo

Beeps

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 16, 2024

Eyebrow filler

I’ve used this pencil as an eyebrow filler for years. It’s a perfect match and doesn’t wear off or smudge. It lasts several months too!

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

May 04, 2024

Love this eye pencil!

I started using Jane Iredale products many years ago when recommended by my aesthetician. I have many allergies and skin sensitivities so I was happy to find this product. The eye pencil glides on smoothly and is easy to remove. My eyes would water throughout the day with other eye products, but I never have a problem with this eye pencil. The brown color is perfect with my hazel eyes and blonde hair.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

March 23, 2024

Great eye pencil

I really love how easily this pencil glides on and the black/grey colour is perfect...dark enough without being too dark. It smudges easily too and then sets. Zero irritation for my sensitive eyes/skin.

Profile Photo

Englady

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

January 10, 2024

jane iredale eye pencil

i have used this twice, it goes on smooth and does not smudge. I like it.

Profile Photo

connieb

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

December 25, 2023

Does not smudge during day.

I've used this product for a few years because of the ingredient quality and staying power. Having green eyes & dark brown hair, I find that 3 shades work for me: Basic Black for evening lighting and Black Grey or Black Brown to enhance my eye color more softly during the day.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

November 25, 2023

Smooth

This Jane Iredale eye pencil goes on easily and smoothly. The black/grey color is perfect, not too dark and not too light. But the best thing is that I can sharpen it to my satisfaction.

Profile Photo

Delighted

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

October 06, 2023

a staple

Just a great classic black pencil eyeliner. Very reliable and does the job for a smokey eye look.

Profile Photo

arielledmd

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

September 17, 2023

Nice eye pencil

I purchased this in brown, it’s a nice shade not harsh, goes on smoothly

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

September 16, 2023

Jane iredale eyeliner

My favorite shade is navy blue which is difficult to find. Pencil sharpens beautiful, no waste trying to get it to a point. I always buy 2 to make sure I never run out.

Profile Photo

Buffie

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

July 24, 2023

Just as described

This eye pencil is great. I wanted it for under my eyes. Kind of a soft line effect. It’s a perfect color and does exactly what I’d hoped!!

Profile Photo

Margay

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

June 26, 2023

Great eyeliner

This eyeliner goes on so smooth and does not smudge. For a matte look this eyeliner is my Goto and how easy it is to apply is a huge benefit.

Profile Photo

Calivixen

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

April 01, 2023

Taupe Eye Pencil

I've always used a dark brown pencil in past years, but as I am getting a little more silver, I find that this pencil compliments my hazel eyes and light skin tone. It is just enough!

Profile Photo

HappyLady

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful


Loading
Return to the top