Reviews For stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner
Stila waterproof eyeliner
I like this eyeliner for its staying power and the fact that it can be smudged, but my only complaint (hence 4 stars) is that it is so thin that it can break off easily! Other than that, its a great product!
Dede50
Verified Purchase
Stila Eye liner
This is very good eyeliner. Easy to apply, stays on and feels good. My only disappointment is the color--vivid violet is not a bright color purple. It is very dark and almost looks like a dark brown.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
soft smudge
Very true colors, does just what it says it does, a soft rubbing gives you the smudge look.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
I like it...
I can only write a review as to how this holds up on the water line, not the eyelid skin. I use a different kind of product for the eyelid skin. This is very rich in color and goes on dark. Much better than many other brands I have tried - including top sellers. It stays dark throughout the day but it does bleed a bit onto the surrounding skin if I do not put enough setting powder or eye shadow in on the areas surrounding the water line (this happens much into the day - not immediately). I will most likely purchase this product again, as I really do like its richness. I just wish it didnt bleed later in the day when used on the waterline.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Love it!
I use this when we go boating, and I dont have to worry about it coming off when we swim. It applies so smoothly. I will continue to buy.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Stila waterproof smudge stick eyeliner
I love these eyeliners. I use a dark one on lashline then just above it use the white pearle. helps to make my hooded eyes be seen. This product will last all day and night for me as long as I keep my moisturizer and any oil base product from it.
sprygal
Verified Purchase
Nice eyeliner
I bought the brown color of this eyeliner and I have been using it frequently. Its a nice brown color with flecks of shimmer that make my eye pop. It does smudge a bit in my under-eye area, which I dont love, but the shimmer flecks help to make it look good anyway.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Great Product: not for sensitive eyes
I LOVE the pigment! It stayed put better than any other liner I've ever tried. HOWEVER, I must have some kind of issue because it made my eyes tear up and blur my vision due to an oily residue. I'm certain that it's me and not the product but if you have sensitive eyes, be aware that it MIGHT wear the same for you.
LovelySkin Customer
Verified Purchase
Review Summary
Have you purchased this product? Write a Review
