Return to Product Details
Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Eyeliner - Espresso Brown

Reviews For Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Eyeliner

$29.00
19 Reviews
November 30, 2025

Eyeliner in Plum

Easy to apply and remove with no irritation, would purchase again

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

from Massachusetts

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

November 04, 2025

Favorite one

This is a favorite eye liner from Laura Mercier! It’s the only brand I can use near my eyes. Most eyeliners irritate and make me itch, especially when wearing contact lens. This one, in plum is very striking on hazel/green eyes. It’s easy to blend and create a soft subtle line that makes your eyes pop!

Profile Picture for Jasmine

goldenear007

Age Group: 50-59

Straight Hair

Mature Skin

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

October 27, 2025

The only liner you need

Hands down best liner for the waterline.

Profile Photo

lss

from California

Age Group: 50-59

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

September 24, 2025

Great eyeliner

This eyeliner applies smoothly and is an excellent color for medium blondes.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

from Alabama

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

August 08, 2025

Beautiful Color

I ordered this in bronze and will no doubt order again. The color is amazing. But I have to agree with other reviews that it's a challenge to sharpen.

Profile Photo

SuZu

from New York

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

June 20, 2025

Love this liner!

Great liner. Stays on all day but easy to remove with water. Now, send me the sharpener. Wish there was one included with the pencil.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

May 23, 2025

Laura Mercier Caviar Tightline Eyeliner (Bronze)

This glides on like a dream. I wish the bronze color was the tiniest bit darker, but I have olive skin so someone whose skin is more fair might think it's just perfect. It's a unique color for sure, so it's a good addition to your makeup bag if you're on the fence. :)

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

May 03, 2025

So far so great

other companies have discontinued an eggplant colored liner. Having found this liner, it is a lovely color and stays on all day.

Profile Photo

Dalebiosense

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

April 25, 2025

Very good eyeliner

I have always used Laura Mercier tightliner in the small vial with a brush, it's nice that they came out with a pencil. Still does not smear under your eyes so that's great for me!

Profile Photo

NancyC

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

April 19, 2025

Missing dark plum caviar stick

That’s been discontinued, but this is an acceptable substitute. Goes on smoothly and blendable. I do not like that it is not self sharpening. It’s hard to get a straight sharpening line with the wood and am often scratching my lid.

Profile Photo

Franlamster

Verified Purchase

2 people found this helpful

April 11, 2025

Best yet

I've tried a lot of pencil eyeliners and this is definitely the best so far. I can get a thin line with full coverage on my lids. It stays put all day. Definitely recommend this.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

March 13, 2025

Great eyeliner

This eyeliner works great. I bought the slate gray color. It goes on easily without tugging and doesn't smudge throughout the day. It has a nice metal cap too. This is great because I find that the plastic caps that most eyeliners come with crack over time. The color is as pictured.

Profile Photo

Chatty

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

March 10, 2025

Challenging Pencil Liner

I removed the lid to discover that the color tip was broken. When I contacted Customer Service I was told it’s essential to remove the lid without tipping it to avoid breakage. I have used many pencil liners without having any issues removing the lid. To my chagrin, it is not self-sharpening. It is a very thin pencil. Finding a sharpener will also be challenging. All that said, the color looks pretty and should glide on.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

February 28, 2025

Great Liner

Love this liner. It goes on very smoothly!

Profile Photo

RhondaR

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

January 17, 2025

No pulling on eyelid

The eyeliner glided on without pulling the eyelid or irritating my sensitive eyes. It is easy to make a thin line or blend with the help of a brush. I wasn’t sure how to sharpen, but gave it a try with a regular sharpener and it worked. I recommend the smoke dark gray color for a softer look.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

January 16, 2025

Worth it!

This eyeliner goes on so smooth and the formula is great. I have super sensitive eyes and found this to be very gentle and non irritating while wearing it all day!

Profile Photo

Mysty

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

September 02, 2024

Great Liner

Easy to apply and the liner does not run.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

1 person found this helpful

July 07, 2024

Holds up but color is very dark

This liner does not run even when playing tennis. There are many liners like this one that perform as well at a lower price - but I purchased on sale so it was reasonable. It comes off with my oil makeup remover quite easily. I took a star off for the color. I ordered the dark plum -this liner is very dark...almost a dark brown - which fine but I thought it would have more of a purple hue to it.

Profile Photo

BMY

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

June 26, 2024

Happy with the purchase!

The cocoa shade is beautiful. Easy to apply to get the look you want. Will definitely consider other colors. Great staying power.

Profile Photo

LovelySkin Customer

Verified Purchase

0 people found this helpful

19 Reviews

Have you purchased this product? Write a Review


Loading
Return to the top